This is a preview of the content in our Florence Art & Culture app. Get the app to:
  • Read offline
  • Remove ads
  • Add Map function to find sites, as well as your own custom locations (your hotel...)
  • Build a list of your own favourites
  • Search the contents with our advanced text search functionality
  • ... and more!
iOS App Store Google Play


The Heresy of Science

Portrait of Galileo by Rubens

Born in 1564, the young Galileo was nurtured in the lofty intellectual environment of Late Renaissance Tuscany. His father introduced him early to the Medici academies, where he was drawn irresistibly to mathematics from an early age.

Before Galileo was appointed professor of mathematics at Pisa (1589) and Padua (1592), all scientific learning came from books arguing for or against Aristotle’s writings. Galileo taught that you could learn much more by studying nature, and in the process became the founding father of experimental physics – he showed that air had weight by weighing a pig’s bladder full of air, then puncturing it to show the difference; he defied the Aristotelian concept of opposites in nature by inventing the principle of the thermometer, demonstrating that hot and cold were merely relative aspects of the same phenomenon, which he called temperature; he debunked Aristotle’s precept that heavy bodies had a tendency to fall and light ones to rise with his famous Leaning Tower experiment, when he dropped variously sized balls and bullets and weights simultaneously and they all hit the ground at once.

In 1609, news reached Galileo of a Dutch spectacle-maker who had made a pipe with lenses that enabled one to see ships far out to sea. Galileo quickly put together one of his own with a convex lens in front, and a concave lens behind, that he soon improved to make the first telescope – with a magnification power of 30.

Even so, when Galileo pointed his instrument at the heavens, it was an incredible revelation: he was the first man ever to see the surface of the moon, the moons of Jupiter, what appeared to be ears on Saturn (his telescope was too weak to discern the rings), the phases of Venus, the the Milky Way, and sunspots, although the last discovery permanently affected his eyesight.

Galileo's Notes the discovery of Jupiter's moons

In 1610 he published all his discoveries in a little book called Sidereus Nuncius, ‘The Starry Messenger’. An instant celebrity, Cosimo de’ Medici made him Grand Ducal mathematician and philosopher. Galileo (along with many Jesuits) had long believed in Copernicus’s De Revolutionibus Orbium Coelestium (1543) and its theory that the earth revolved around the sun.

However, by 1615, so many theologians thought that the theory was inconsistent with biblical teachings that, in spite all of Galileo’s energetic efforts in Rome, De Revolutionibus was placed on the Index of prohibited books until it could be amended with a statement that it was an unproved hypothesis. The Holy Office then forbade Galileo from teaching it.

In 1624, the 60-year-old scientist went to Rome and asked Pope Urban VIII to discuss Copernicanism in a new book, emphasizing to the Pope that it was to the glory of the Catholic Church to promote learning. He spent the next five years writing (in Italian, instead of the usual Latin) the first-ever book of popular science, a witty and lively masterpiece called the Dialogue on the Two Chief Systems of the World, in which three characters (a Copernican, an Aristotelian and an amateur) discuss the two systems, with the Copernican clearly winning the argument.

Although at first greeted with enthusiasm, the Dialogue was soon withdrawn by the Pope, who believed he had been duped. A special commission he set up agreed with him: that Galileo was advocating an unproved hypothesis as the truth and disobeying the order from the Holy Office of 17 years ago not to teach Copernicanism. In the famous Inquisition trial he was accused of relapsing – a much worse crime than heresy – and made to recant his belief that the earth moved, although, legend has it, with the famous aside:‘eppur si muove!’, ‘But it does move!’

The Inquisition was lenient with the old man, first placing him under house arrest in Siena, and then in his villa at Arcetri, just outside Florence. There he wrote his even more influential The Two New Sciences (1638), on the mathematical study of motion and the strength of materials, a work that became the basis for the study of physics as a science. He died in 1642, if not a martyr, at least a hero to science, although in 1992, all was forgiven when Pope John Paul II wrote

Thanks to his intuition as a brilliant physicist and by relying on different arguments, Galileo, who practically invented the experimental method, understood why only the sun could function as the centre of the world, as it was then known, that is to say, as a planetary system. The error of the theologians of the time, when they maintained the centrality of the Earth, was to think that our understanding of the physical world's structure was, in some way, imposed by the literal sense of Sacred Scripture....

In 1737, when Galileo's body was removed to a monumental tomb in Santa Croce next to his beloved daughter Virginia (Sister Maria Celeste), his admirers pinched three fingers, a tooth and a vertebra. His middle finger has long been on display in Florence's Museo di Storia della Scienza (now renamed the Museo Galileo); in 2009 when his other fingers and tooth appeared in an auction, they were purchased by the city and reunited with the other bits. His vertebra, however, is in Padua.

Text © Dana Facaros and Michael Pauls

Images by: PD Art